Tuesday is the 51st anniversary of The Wreck Of The Edmund Fitzgerald. As years have passed, we've learned more about the ship from historians, authors, investigators, and boat enthusiasts. If you're like me, your Facebook feed is full of stories, and I just discovered one that sent me down a rabbit hole, finding out much more than I ever realized.

What Sank The Edmund Fitzgerald?

The ship sank at Whitefish Point after taking on water, losing its radar, and sailing blind into the storm of the century. We may never know what actually led to the sinking. Some believe it was unsecured hatch covers that allowed water into the cargo hold. Another theory is that it scraped the ground earlier in the storm, causing structural damage and water to get in. Rogue waves and the ship breaking in half have also been considered.

Doomed From The Beginning?

One of the things a lot of people don't know is the doomed christening of the Edmund Fitzgerald. During a christening, a bottle of champagne is broken across the hull. It's long been considered a bad omen if the bottle doesn't break. On June 17, 1958, the wife of Edmund Fitzgerald, Elizabeth, tried to break the bottle on the hull; it didn't break. She tried again; it didn't break. On the third attempt, it finally broke.

Disastrous Launch Results In Fatality And Crash

The launch was delayed when the crew struggled to release the blocks from the keel of the ship. When the ship was finally launched sideways, it created a huge wave that doused the spectators, and the ship crashed into a pier. The wave demolished a VIP grandstand. A spectator died from a heart attack during all the commotion.

Bob Campbell NOAA
Bob Campbell NOAA

Great Safety Record For Years - Then Accidents Started

The Fitz won a safety award in 1969, shortly after that the Fitz ran aground in the same year. In 1970, she collided with the SS Hocheclaga. Later that same year, she struck the wall of a lock, which happened again in 1973 and 1974. None of the damage was considered severe or even that unusual. Still, you have to wonder if long-term damage may have occurred, weakening the hull strength.

Did The Captain Push The Fitzgerald Too Hard?

I actually have a friend who was a sailor on the Great Lakes during that time. He had worked on the Edmund Fitzgerald a few weeks before the wreck. Luckily, he was transferred to a different ship before the fateful voyage. I asked him what he thought about the Fitz, and he said crew members worried the captain was taking too many chances and pushing the ship too hard. That aligns with what some historians and other captains have theorized.

Read More: New Documentary Debuts On Anniversary Of Wreck Of The Edmund Fitzgerald

240 Other Ships Lie On The Bottom Of Lake Superior Near The Fitzgerald

Google Maps
Google Maps

The Edmund Fitzgerald is the largest and most recent sinking of a freighter on the Great Lakes. But there have been shipwrecks near Whitefish Point since 1817. Over the next 150 years, 240 ships have sunk near and around Whitefish Point.

Draining Lake Superior to Reveal Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald

Seeing the wreck of the S.S. Edmund Fitzgerald with any clarity is almost impossible in the cloudy waters of Lake Superior. Blue Star Line has used the latest digital imagery to pull the plug on Michigan's largest lake, to give us a one-of-a-kind view of our state's most legendary sunken ship.

Gallery Credit: Scott Clow

More From Minnesota Now